David Thompson
Subscribe

Categories

Blog powered by Typepad

« Apostates! | Main | Low Noise »

June 19, 2007

Comments

AntiCitizenOne

If you think that's moronic wait for this.

Pakistan religious affairs minister Mohammed Ijaz ul-Haq offers calming words following Salman Rushdie’s knighthood:

"The West is accusing Muslims of extremism and terrorism. If someone exploded a bomb on his body, he would be right to do so unless the British government apologizes and withdraws the ‘sir’ title,” ul-Haq said.


HT: http://timblair.net/ee/index.php/weblog/muslims_accused/

Tom Freeman

I'm still too busy being offended by the knighthood given to Iqbal Sacranie (ex of the MCB). The granting of a knighthood to him can only do harm to the image of our country in the eyes of hundreds of millions of sensible people across the world.

David

Quite.

politics forum

The cartoon lists a bunch of problems that it claims Muslim societies have. So will Western government and society mocking the most sensitive issues of Islam make those problems better or worse?

David

Politics Forum,

I suppose one might turn the question around. Given Muhammad’s role as mandate in so many of those problems, how will they be solved if Muhammad and his purported teachings remain beyond criticism?

This touches on issues raised in an earlier post. The example given concerns the treatment of women, but one might make a similar case regarding terrorism and intolerance, both of which are sanctioned by some of Muhammad’s purported ‘revelations’.

http://davidthompson.typepad.com/davidthompson/2007/06/empty_gestures.html

“‘Believing’ in the equality of women is very easy and conveniently vague, especially if one is unwilling to challenge the means by which cruelty and coercion are perpetuated, justified and enforced. Unless one is prepared to address the theological nuts and bolts of the matter, and prepared to risk offending some religious ‘sentiments’, it’s hard to see what kind of ‘firm stand’ has actually been taken.”

It isn’t clear to me how moderate believers can challenge the ‘divine’ sanction of such behaviour in an effective way without questioning Muhammad’s role in their own beliefs.

Brendan_2

I do believe... yes, I am quite sure that, you have in fact, published... a MOTOON! You insensitive browbeater! Do please publish all threats and coercion you receive for your callousness so we may better understand the ‘religion of peace’.

clazy

I've been watching the Panorama documentary. Wow. I never realized how, uh, unhelpful the MCB and Sacranie have been. How did that guy ever get knighted? Rushdie had to get his own knighthood if only to attempt some kind of reparation.

clazy

Why did I hold back? Sacranie is despicable, hateful. It disgusts me to watch him dissemble. What a great piece.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Blogroll