David Thompson
Subscribe

Categories

Blog powered by Typepad

« Comedy of Manners | Main | Human Bean Juice »

July 18, 2008

Comments

Anna

I want a giant carboard Ghandi. And a cat tank.

Paul

Those Cadillacs. Ooooh....

andym

The link to "Dismantling old buildings" is broken at the moment, here's one from youtube:

andym

Sorry messed that up, try:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jwf9LoS9Xt8

John D

Re: Hobsbawm -

"Lifelong devotion to Communism destroyed him as a thinker or interpreter of events."

Spot on.

David

John,

Indeed. Though Hobsbawm’s devotion to that sad, sick religion did more than blunt his faculties and make him wilfully dishonest. It also made him an apologist for evil, repeatedly, and thus a little evil himself. And while ageing Nazis often come belatedly to understand shame, many enthusiasts of Communism remain unrepentant, despite all they know (but often pretend they don’t).

Horace Dunn

John and David

Too right.

It is astonishing that someone as shabby and inhuman as Hobsbawm should be president of a major academic institution, Birkbeck College. Birckbeck itself seems quite happy with have a supporter of tyranny and murder on its masthead and, far from turning a blind eye to the fact, seems to relish it. See this fawning article on the College’s website:

http://www.bbk.ac.uk/about_us/publications/bbk/bbk22/history

The casual tone of this remark:

“While most other left-wing historians had abandoned their Marxist credentials after the Soviet suppression of the 1956 Budapest uprising, Hobsbawm retained his Communist Party membership …”

leaves me speechless.

David

Horace,

It’s a monstrous delusion that’s excused much too casually, as if it were merely a youthful fashion gaffe, like a taste for dodgy pop music:

http://davidthompson.typepad.com/davidthompson/2008/05/youthful-indisc.html

In some quarters it’s apparently looked on as some kind of credential or mark of credibility. The morality of which escapes me.

pt591

Here's a clip of the earthquake dampener moving (a little bit):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NYSgd1XSZXc

John D

Oliver Kamm on Hobsbawm:

http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/comment/thunderer/article460555.ece

"Hobsbawm was asked by Michael Ignatieff in a BBC interview in 1994: “What (your view) comes down to is saying that had the radiant tomorrow actually been created, the loss of 15, 20 million people might have been justified?” He replied: “Yes.”"

David

John,

Thanks for that. Like Seumas Milne, Hobsbawm is an example of how persistent and wilful misreading of events becomes entrenched fantasy and, thus, duplicity and pathology. But apparently it’s a kind of duplicity and pathology that’s to be indulged, even rewarded. And, as Kamm points out, the idea that Lenin was “not merely pragmatically intolerant but congenitally bloodthirsty is too *unsophisticated* a thesis to merit Hobsbawm’s consideration.”

rxc

The French have had wine in aluminum bottles (essentially cans with bottle shapes) for years. It is sold in boat stores to yachties who need some vin while at sea.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Amazon-co-uk-logo
Amazon Link

Blogroll