David Thompson
Subscribe

Categories

Blog powered by Typepad

« Mixtape (3) | Main | Secret Identities »

November 14, 2008

Comments

John D

Re Watchmen, looks like Synder's changed the ending. No more squid!
http://www.watchmencomicmovie.com/111008-watchmen-movie-zack-snyder-ending-changed.php

David

“No more squid!”

Yes, the purists are unhappy. But the “squid” was always going to be a sticking point. It’s outlandish even by the comic’s own standards and could very easily look silly on film. (It’s kind of silly in the comic and, I think, the weakest part of the story.) I don’t know how well the revised ending will work and a lot of other details will have had to be changed to make it fit; but I can see why Snyder shied away from mixing horrific tragedy with interdimensional calamari.

Anna

The music sounds like a Philip Glass/Queen mash-up. Still looks good though, squid or no squid.

carbon based lifeform

Philip Glass and Queen -together at last!

David

Much as I love the idea of a Philip Glass / Queen collaboration (and who wouldn’t?), I’m told the beat combo in question is Muse.

JuliaM

This one's clearly more of a 'appeal to the masses who haven't read the book' trailer.

John D

It must be a tough film to sell. The trailers make it look like it's full of action and explosions, which it won't be if it's anything like the book.

Baltar's Beard

No squid? Noooooo!!!

Like the "real" Photoshop, btw.

rv

Ayn Rand? (Michael Portillo?!)

David

rv,

I’m not smitten by Rand, if that’s what you’re asking. But Portillo provides a serviceable introduction to an interesting figure, which she is, regardless of what one makes of her politics or writing.

Jason Bontrager

The costumed heroes ("masks") never referred to themselves as "the Watchmen" in the book, that was a bit of graffiti. Rorschach never went on about vengeance either AFAIR.

I'm going to have to develop a "forget the book" mindset before going to see this I think. Sad, I would've liked a loyal adaptation, even with the Squid. With modern F/X, that could've looked like a Lovecraftian Horror and been fairly plausible (at least given the existence of such things as Dr. Manhattan).

David

Jason,

“…that was a bit of graffiti.”

If you listen carefully, it sounds like the dialogue is edited for the trailer. It’s possible that “watchmen” is being used as a generic term for costumed heroes, and not necessarily as the name of the actual group of protagonists. If so, I suppose someone still felt it necessary to link the title to something literal in the film, rather than have it hanging about as an allusion.

“I would’ve liked a loyal adaptation, even with the Squid.”

A Lovecraftian approach might have been fun, though I still have my doubts about giant psychic calamari, which always seemed a tad outré even given Dr Manhattan and smiley craters on Mars.

“I’m going to have to develop a ‘forget the book’ mindset before going to see this I think.”

Probably for the best. It is, after all, a film and should first work (or not) on its own, filmic, terms. It’s a bit like hoping for a faithful adaptation of Solaris. If you stick meticulously to Lem’s book, you’ll get a pretty terrible film.

andy

David: I've noticed a recent concentration on bacon - do you have a obsession/fetish with the stuff?

(btw: can't wait for Watchmen!)

David

Can’t a guy note the uses of salted meats without being viewed as... suspicious? :)

Anna

No.

Cambias

It's when you aren't obsessed about bacon that you're acting abnormal. All right-thinking people are bacon-obsessed. Except the Shakespeare's-plays kind of Bacon obsessives.

wayne fontes

David, unless I've missed something you've been remiss and not informed your audience about the wonders of bacon salt. Imagine the joys of flavoring your food with salt flavored by a meat which is flavored with salt. The good people at J&D's are even promising Baconnaise™ soon. This is the type of innovation that illustrates why the Russkies could never catch us.


http://www.jdfoods.net/ourstory.php
http://www.baconsalt.com/

David

Wayne,

I do try to keep abreast of all bacon-related innovation.

http://davidthompson.typepad.com/davidthompson/2008/06/world-of-pig.html

Steve in San Diego

Well, probably everybody has seen this already.

Anyway, if you will, a couple of numbers from "Gold Diggers of 1933." I am inclined to think it's worth taking a look at right now.

"Remember My Forgotten Man:"

http://www.youtube.com/user/lodrochoying

"We're in the Money:"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8xTTWHMCXdg

There's a lot of stuff in there Dave, and maybe you've heard something interesting. One small thing - what is with the foreign language section in clip the second? Boasting to the Soviets? Code for locations of U.S. Army bases?

///Perhaps I am a lazy scalliwag. Google exists, I could look it up for myself, but, I got a job and a kid. My car is making a funny noise. My mortgage payment is big. Big, I tells you.

I tell my wife (Ph.D. Chemist, originally from mainland China), "Remember your forgotten man." She yells, "What the hell are you talking about!" After that, we watch "Jeopardy." Our kid is fine. Thanks for asking.

sk60

Anna,

"The music sounds like a Philip Glass/Queen mash-up."

It's Muse: 'Take A Bow.'

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7ghqoYxmaUE

The Alan King clip is very funny David.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Blogroll