David Thompson


Blog powered by Typepad

« Little Knots of Agony | Main | It’s Harder Than You’d Think »

October 14, 2013



The Mike Power article is pure Guardian –smug and totally joyless.

Also, the Plastic Spatula of Oppression™. :-)


The Mike Power article is pure Guardian –smug and totally joyless.

Like a lot of Guardian commentary, it does convey a certain… self-satisfied sourness. It’s almost as if the challenge is to find some way to disapprove of – and look down on - anything that lots of people enjoy. Whatever the thing is, it has to be “problematised” and revealed as somehow unjust, and no amount of contrivance will impede that mission. As if the typical barbecue could only be endured and pass without critique if you aren’t as enlightened as a Guardian columnist.

Steve 2

They really should remake Zardoz for the Twitter generation. The spatula is good, the penis is evil!

If that doesn't tempt Sean Connery out of retirement I'll eat my red vinyl mankini.


Apparently, the “diffusion” of the family unit – which is to say, absent fathers, hardship and subsequent dependence on the state – “is one of the most exciting things to happen to the American social pattern since sexual liberation.”

Incredible. Do these idiots actually *want* generational dependency?


Do these idiots actually *want* generational dependency?

It’s hard to be sure what Ms Schwartz wants, beyond being thought of as terribly radical and subversive. Her avoidance of any actual data or marked correlations suggests she’s not particularly interested in how her anti-bourgeois posturing would play out in real life. And does play out in real life.

For a less narcissistic view and some actual information, see Heather Mac Donald’s articles here and here. The statistics are not encouraging, to say the least. There’s also this podcast, in which she describes various “community organisers” pretending that Chicago’s poverty and crime stats have nothing whatsoever to do with those “diffused” family arrangements advocated by Madeleine Schwartz, Laurie Penny et al. The idea that sub-optimal family arrangements might often have sub-optimal outcomes was, she discovered, practically taboo. As Mac Donald points out, “The sky-high illegitimacy rate meant that black boys were growing up in a world in which it was normal to impregnate a girl and then take off. When a boy is raised without any social expectation that he will support his children and marry his children’s mother, he fails to learn the most fundamental lesson of personal responsibility.”

Which doesn’t sound like a recipe for “one of the most exciting things to happen to the American social pattern since sexual liberation.”


Thank you for mentioning Heather Mac Donald. I am in awe of her work, and I often go to City Journal to find more of it.


Do these idiots actually *want* generational dependency?


It validates their belief that Whitey is still as racist as ever and that the po' black folks need their saving grace terribly, terribly much.

If the blacks were to rise out of poverty, then what's a do-gooder to do? Whom are they going to champion next, poor white folk?

See my comments in the previous thread about my scuffle on Twitter with these folks. If I were to stroll into the projects and offer to help them better their lot, they'd accuse me of trying to make them "act white," beat me to a pulp, and send the dog over to piss on me.

I do NOT exaggerate. You should see what they did to Bill Cosby when he suggested that kids pull up their pants, point their brims forward, and learn to speak Standard English. If they'll excoriate him, they'll murder me.



"Revolution is totally gonna 'appen" says rich ex-junkie comedian with a messiah complex.

"I’m sure you won’t be astonished to learn that I, Russell Brand, the stand-up comedian have not dreamt up a viable replacement for the Free Market between gigs and joyless trysts but I know all over the world, in the face of incredible obstruction and resistance, people are inaugurating economic systems that are founded on fairness and egalitarianism. Worker run factories, villages without currency and even in Blighty, council estates bulk buying shopping to make benefits go further."

The comments to this entry are closed.